I am not a technophobe.
I grew up enthralled by the science fiction of Star Trek and the science reality of Apollo 11. I am equally fascinated by the inner workings of the cell and the outer workings of the universe. And, although I wear an analog watch, run without earbuds, write with a fountain pen and read books made of paper rather than pixels, I do so, in part just to nurture the technology between my ears.
That being said, as the events of last week reminded us rather dramatically, the extraordinary advance of technology brings with it, not just the promise of improvement but the threat of disaster. Indeed, in broad terms, the greatest risk facing investors today may be the juxtaposition of ever more powerful technology, across multiple dimensions, with the wholly inadequate political and regulatory systems needed to control it. For voters and those they elect, this speaks to the need for a serious reassessment of the importance of regulation. For investors, it underscores the need to build portfolios which, if they can’t be expected to survive “apocalypse now”, should at least be constructed to weather “something really bad soon”.
Technology and the Business Cycle
The U.S. economy has seen just two recessions in the past 25 years, continuing a pattern of greater economic stability that emerged in the 1980s. The traditional business cycle, in the simplest terms, was characterized by a too strong economy, leading to inflation and higher interest rates followed by a sharp slowdown in demand, amplified by layoffs and the need to reduce inventories. However, over time, the economy has become less prone to inflation, less sensitive to interest rates and, with better inventory controls and a larger, more stable services sector, less prone to sharp downturns in output.
But even as the economy has become more stable internally, it has been bombarded by outside shocks that have a common thread of powerful technology and ineffective regulation.
- 9/11 was the result of both. Civilian jet aircraft, although they have been around for many decades are, of course, tremendously powerful weapons in the hands of those who are both homicidal and suicidal. In addition, U.S. intelligence failed to notice that the future hijackers were training at U.S. flight schools or connect the dots, even when they arrested one of them.
- The Great Financial Crisis had its origin in a lack of regulation in the mortgage market, which supercharged a housing bubble. However, an even greater problem in the subsequent crisis was the proliferation of packaged sub-prime mortgages and derivatives such as credit default swaps, These financial innovations, which could broadly be classified as new financial technology, were very hard to value in a free-falling market and, in retrospect, not subject to nearly enough thoughtful regulation.
- While the origins of the COVID19 pandemic are still disputed, a leading theory is that it was the result of an accidental lab-leak by a researcher at the Wuhan Institute of Virology. If so, it is another example of regulation not being adequate to contain a powerful technology, with truly disastrous consequences.
The Technology Threat
Going forward, there are plenty of other threats:
It is more than eighty years since a nuclear weapon was used in war. However, when the nuclear non-proliferation treaty was signed in 1968, there were only five nations with nuclear weapons: the U.S., the USSR, the UK, France and China. Today, there are at least four more, India, Pakistan, North Korea and Israel, while Iran has been trying to develop this capability. While there seems to be no imminent threat of a nuclear attack, there is an inherent danger in the growing number of countries with unstable and autocratic leaders who have this capability.
In biotechnology, the development of gene editors such as CRISPER and its descendants could open up a pandora’s box of human genetic manipulation for desirable features such as intelligence or strength but also with the possibility of Frankenstein-like errors.
In finance, the advent of assets such as cryptocurrencies and NFTs, with little positive economic value, but with well-funded political support, or the movement of capital from heavily-regulated public markets to lightly-regulated private assets could ultimately destabilize markets.
And then there is AI.
There is the medium to long-term threat that AI could result in massive layoffs. Generally, with technological advances, this isn’t the case, as the new technology increases living standards and consumers always find something else they want to buy. However, there could be more of a threat from AI, partly because of the sheer volume of tasks that AI and robotics could eventually take over and partly because, in an increasingly K-shaped economy, middle- and lower-income consumers may not see enough financial benefit from AI productivity gains to power broad consumer demand.
Even more seriously, AI technology could aid hackers intent on attacking electric utilities or financial systems. Of course, utility companies and banks also use AI in defending their systems but it is an uncomfortable arms race. And then there is the threat of AI acting autonomously either to defend itself or attack other systems. The “Hugging Face” incident over the summer, in which AI agents escaped their so-called sandbox and hacked into the Hugging Face platform to improve their score on a hacking test didn’t have significant economic repercussions. However, it certainly opened up the possibility of more serious autonomous attacks down the road.
Prospects for Thoughtful Regulation
There are other longer-term threats embedded in the technology of today. Evidence suggests social media feeds over smart phones are reducing personal contacts and leading to higher levels of depression among teens. They could also, in time, lead to lower levels of literacy and overall education.
Global warming is continuing, with 2026 currently tied with 2024 as the second warmest globally since at least the 1850s, with gradual but growing impacts on sea levels and flooding.
And there is the danger that a combination of AI and social media could seriously undermine democracy, with voters being increasingly misled by well-tuned algorithms pumping out false information.
All of this cries out for some more thoughtful and effective regulation. However, there are at least four major impediments to such regulation actually mitigating these threats.
First, at least within the United States, there is a general aversion to regulation. Since the 1980s, politicians have routinely been elected on platforms promising to reduce regulation. The argument is that regulation tends to impede economic growth, which is certainly true – at least in the short run. However, decades of antipathy to regulation, along with more recent budget and staff cuts across a wide swath of regulators, means that much of U.S. regulation now comes in just two flavors – ham-fisted or non-existent.
Second, there is the perverse and pervasive impact of money on U.S. political campaigns. It might well be in the public interest to ban cryptocurrencies altogether. However, since the crypto industry is estimated to have contributed almost half a billion dollars to 2026 midterm election campaigns, it will likely continue to receive preferential treatment from legislators1. This is, of course, a general problem in U.S. politics, where money bends policies towards aiding short-term corporate interests over long-term national interests.
Third, there is a need, in many cases, for agreed-upon global regulation. If, for example, the U.S. were to destroy its nuclear stockpile, unilaterally rein in AI, or enact severe restrictions on carbon emissions and China didn’t, the global threats would persist even as the United States left itself at a comparative disadvantage. This is also a problem within nations where, if one AI company decides, out of an abundance of caution, to limit the growth of its frontier models, competitors will have an incentive to act more recklessly to gain market share. In a widely read recent article, Dario Amodei2, the CEO of Anthropic, laid out a sensible blueprint for how to mitigate risks inherent from AI advancing too fast. The problem is that, for such a program to be effective, all AI labs would have to sign on, while economic and geopolitical incentives would be pulling them in the opposite direction.
And, finally, there is the particularly tricky question of what precisely to target and how to monitor compliance. This was straightforward enough in the case of the 1987 Montreal Protocol, that banned the global production and consumption of chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs), due to the damage they were inflicting on the ozone layer. At their peak, CFCs were produced by only a few dozen plants worldwide, run by roughly a dozen chemical companies. Once all the nations had agreed to ban them, shutting down or converting these plants was not particularly difficult.
However, regulation becomes far more complicated in an area such as AI, where it is really not clear, beforehand, which are the most dangerous innovations and where, should a company want to hide its latest advances, it should not be difficult to do so.
As a result, while the advance of technology suggests the need for more disciplined, unbiased and thoughtful regulation, there’s little reason to believe that that is where we are headed.
Investment Implications
All of this has two obvious implications for how to rebalance portfolios (while keeping a careful eye on tax implications).
First, it is important to reduce portfolio concentration and increase diversification across different asset classes and geographically. If some technology disaster were to unfold, it would likely have different implications for different types of financial and real assets and among different economies.
Second, it is important to take a long, hard look at valuations. This is trickier today than in 2000 or 2008, since it is corporate profits, rather than P/E ratios, that now appear very elevated. However, in times of financial panic, regardless of the triggering event, investors generally gravitate towards those assets with more grounded, rather than speculative, valuations.
There never has been a time in history when technology has promised so much.
If all goes right, the combination of AI and genomics has tremendous potential to cure disease. Nuclear fusion experiments are bringing us ever closer to the holy grail of clean and abundant energy. Advances in robotics and AI can boost productivity, potentially enabling the developed world to enhance living standards, even as more workers enter retirement. Each of these areas, and many others, present investment opportunities as well as promising lifestyle enhancement.
However, today, particularly after four years of extraordinary returns have allowed many investors to achieve their long-term financial goals early, it is just as important to be prepared for the dangers arising from ever-more-powerful technology as to be positioned to benefit from its continuing and growing promise.
