Our April 2026 hot topic "For new retirees: To Roth or not to Roth?", explored a question many new retirees face: Should I convert some of my retirement savings to a Roth IRA? But Roth conversion opportunities may begin before retirement for those holding designated Roth contributions in a 401(k) plan account. With more plans allowing participants to convert eligible existing balances through in-plan Roth rollovers and certain higher-paid participants now required to make catch-up contributions on a Roth basis, there is good reason for advisors to broaden the Roth conversation and take a closer look at the opportunities available inside a client’s 401(k).
For years, the in-plan Roth conversation has largely centered on a familiar question: Should a client make traditional pre-tax or Roth contributions to their 401(k)? While in-plan Roth rollovers have been available as a plan option for years, changes taking effect in 2026 provide additional reasons for financial advisors to broaden that conversation.
For some clients, catch-up contributions must now be made on a Roth basis. And for clients who have accumulated pre-tax savings in their workplace plan, an in-plan Roth conversion may provide another opportunity to build a more tax-diversified retirement portfolio.
For advisors, it may be time to think about Roth through three different lenses: contribute, catch up and convert.
Contribute: Where should the next dollar go?
The traditional Roth decision isn't going away. Participants in a 401(k) plan that offers a designated Roth account can generally choose whether to make elective contributions on a pre-tax or Roth basis.
Pre-tax contributions generally reduce taxable income today, with distributions taxed later. Roth contributions are made with after-tax dollars, but qualified distributions, including earnings, are tax-free. The IRS designated Roth account guidance outlines these basic rules.1
That choice provides advisors with an opportunity to consider a client's current and anticipated future tax circumstances, along with how much of their retirement savings is already held in pre-tax versus Roth accounts.
But beginning in 2026, some clients no longer have complete flexibility when it comes to catch-up contributions.
Catch up: When Roth is no longer optional
Effective January 1, 2026, certain higher-paid participants who make catch-up contributions to a 401(k) must make those contributions on a Roth basis. 2
The rule generally applies to participants aged 50 or older whose prior year Federal Insurance Contributions Act (FICA) wages from the employer sponsoring the plan exceed a specified threshold that is indexed for inflation annually. For determining applicability in 2026, the threshold is $150,000, for 2027 it is $155,000.
For affected clients, that means at least some new retirement savings will begin flowing into Roth, even if they previously favored pre-tax contributions. The standard age-50 catch-up limit is $8,000 in 2026 and $8,500 in 2027. Participants ages 60 through 63 may have a higher $11,250 catch-up limit in 2026 and $11,750 in 2027 if their plan allows. Catch-up contributions are those that exceed $24,500 for 2026 and $25,500 for 2027 or if less, any applicable plan or regulatory limits.
Rather than viewing mandatory Roth catch-up solely as a new retirement plan rule, advisors can use it as a prompt for a broader question: Does the client's overall mix of pre-tax and Roth savings still align with their long-term retirement strategy?
Convert: What about the dollars already accumulated?
For many participants, most of their 401(k) savings may have accumulated on a pre-tax basis. Changing future contributions to Roth, voluntarily or because of the new catch-up requirement, doesn't change the tax treatment of those existing savings.
That's where an often-overlooked plan feature can come into play. A 401(k) plan may permit an in-plan Roth rollover, allowing eligible amounts already held in the plan to be moved to the plan's designated Roth account. Previously untaxed amounts converted are generally included in taxable income for the year of the conversion.
Consider Maria
Maria is 55 and has $350,000 in her 401(k), most of it accumulated on a pre-tax basis. Her 2025 FICA wages from her employer exceeded $150,000, and she plans to make catch-up contributions in 2026. That means her catch-up contributions must be made on a Roth basis.
Maria's plan also permits in-plan Roth conversions. Her advisor uses the new catch-up requirement as an opportunity to step back and review the bigger picture. Should Maria simply begin accumulating Roth savings through her catch-up contributions, or might it also make sense to gradually reposition some of her existing pre-tax savings?
The answer depends on Maria's individual circumstances. A conversion creates taxable income today, so her advisor and tax professional would need to consider the immediate tax cost alongside her longer-term goals. But the important point is that Maria's new Roth catch-up contribution becomes the starting point for a broader planning conversation, not the end of it.
Put the 401(k) into the planning conversation
The expanding role of Roth in workplace plans gives advisors an opportunity to move beyond a simple “pre-tax or Roth?” discussion. Three questions can provide a useful starting point:
- Contribute: How should the client direct new 401(k) contributions?
- Catch up: Does mandatory Roth catch-up apply?
- Convert: Could existing pre-tax assets warrant a closer look?
Not every client will benefit from converting pre-tax assets to Roth. But as Roth becomes a larger part of the 401(k) landscape, understanding what is available inside a client's plan can help uncover planning opportunities that might otherwise be missed.
The Roth decision is no longer simply about where the next contribution goes. It's increasingly about how the different pieces of a client's retirement savings fit together.
Compliance sidebar: Know before you convert
- Check the plan first. In-plan Roth rollovers are optional. Confirm that the client's 401(k) permits them and which amounts are eligible.
- Understand the tax impact. Previously untaxed amounts converted to Roth generally become taxable income in the year of conversion.
- Don't confuse Roth catch-up with conversion. The Roth catch-up requirement is based on prior-year FICA wages from the employer sponsoring the plan. The threshold is $150,000 for 2026 and $155,000 for 2027.
- Coordinate with a tax professional. The potential benefits of a conversion should be evaluated against the client's current tax consequences and broader financial circumstances.
Advisor takeaway: Know what the plan permits, understand which dollars are eligible and evaluate the tax consequences before moving from a Roth conversation to a Roth conversion.
This material is for general educational purposes only and should not be considered individualized investment, tax or legal advice. Individuals should consult appropriate professionals regarding their specific circumstances before making Roth contribution or conversion decisions.
Check out our Guide to Retirement for more information.
