Initial public offerings are back in the headlines, as more than 300 IPOs have priced this year including some historically large offerings. For many investors, an IPO is the first chance to own a business that has spent years growing without being ticker-traded. Pre-IPO companies are typically only accessible through private equity and venture funds. But history suggests that buying at the opening bell is not always a reliable strategy for long-term returns.
In 2025, the average IPO closed its first day of trading 29% above its offer price. That enthusiasm, however, tends to fade. As the chart below shows, average one-year returns after listing have swung widely by decade, from 15% for companies that went public in the 1990s to -11% for companies that listed in the 2000s. These figures are measured from the offer price, so they include the first day’s “pop” that investors buying once the shares begin trading might not capture. Passive index methodologies have also recently changed this year, with some index providers like NASDAQ and Russell allowing mega-IPOs to enter their indices as soon as a few weeks after listing. However, the S&P 500 decided not to change its rules, still requiring a 12-month seasoning period for index inclusion consideration.
How can we explain the wide range of returns from IPOs and the poorer performance this decade so far? Every IPO, of course, is a unique story. But some broad trends are worth considering. Part of the explanation is that more of a company’s growth now happens before it even lists. Companies are staying private for longer. In 2025 the average company going public had been operating for 12 years. They are also getting much bigger while private. The number of venture-backed companies valued at $1 billion or more has grown from roughly 230 in 2016 to around 1,750 today, with a combined valuation of more than $8 trillion. That is a key reason why we are seeing IPOs at valuations that would once have been unthinkable for a newly public company, including some above $1 trillion. The higher interest rate environment, combined with lower quality companies that IPO’d in 2021, have also contributed to the poor performance so far this decade.
Not every venture-backed company will IPO. Some will be acquired, some will fail and some may choose to stay private. Artificial intelligence may strengthen the case for staying private. AI is allowing companies to scale bigger and faster, often with leaner teams. Private ownership, without the corporate bloat and regulations that public companies are saddled with, can give companies an edge, particularly if their business model requires quickly pivoting and going after emerging opportunities, as is the case with companies in the AI ecosystem.
As public and private markets converge, investors should consider building exposure across both. Public markets offer liquidity and breadth, while private equity and venture capital can provide access to the frontier companies of the future at earlier stages of their life cycle. Together, they make up a broad opportunity set for active investment managers.
Importantly, private markets come with their own trade-offs, including illiquidity, higher fees and wider dispersion in manager returns. But for investors who are able to set aside part of their portfolio for longer-term commitments, they can gain access to higher growth companies without waiting for them to IPO.
