Skip to main content
logo
Financial Professional Login
Welcome
Log in for exclusive access and a personalised experience
Log in Sign up
Benefits of creating a free account
  • Customise Guide to the Markets to create a version with your favourite slides
  • Utilise our adviser-only Digital Portfolio Insights tool
  • Unlock expert commentary from Michael Cembalest and access our annual Long-Term Capital Market Assumptions
Hello
  • My Collections
    View saved content and presentation slides
  • Portfolio Analysis
  • Funds
    Overview

    Fund Listing

    • Mutual Funds
    • ETFs
    • ETF Range
    • How to Invest

    Capabilities

    • Alternatives
    • Equities
    • Fixed Income
    • ETF Investing

    In Focus

    • Investing for Income
    • Investing for Fixed Income
    • Investing for Growth
    • Investing for Sustainability
    • Investing for Alternatives
  • Insights
    Overview

    Market Insights

    • Market Insights Overview
    • Guide to the Markets
    • Guide to Alternatives
    • Guide to Investing in Asia
    • Weekly Market Recap
    • On the Minds of Investors
    • Podcasts
    • U.S. Policy Pulse Hub
    • Solving for Fixed Income
    • Eye on the Market

    Portfolio Insights

    • Portfolio Insights Overview
    • Guide to ETFs
    • Global Asset Allocation Views
    • Global Equity Views
    • Global Fixed Income Views
    • Sustainable Investing
    • Alternatives Insights
    • Long-Term Capital Market Assumptions
  • Investment Ideas
    Overview
    • Latest ideas
    • Alternatives Outlook
    • Sustainable investing
  • Resources
    Overview
    • Multimedia
    • Insights App
    • Digital Portfolio Insights
    • Announcements
  • About Us
    Overview
    • Awards
    • Diversity, Equity and Inclusion
    • Spectrum: Our Investment Platform
    • Our Leadership Team
  • Contact Us
  • Role
  • Country
Hello
  • My Collections
    View saved content and presentation slides
  • Portfolio Analysis
  • Log out
Financial Professional Login
Welcome
Log in for exclusive access and a personalised experience
Log in Sign up
Benefits of creating a free account
  • Customise Guide to the Markets to create a version with your favourite slides
  • Utilise our adviser-only Digital Portfolio Insights tool
  • Unlock expert commentary from Michael Cembalest and access our annual Long-Term Capital Market Assumptions
Log out
Search
Menu
Search
You are about to leave the site Close
J.P. Morgan Asset Management’s website and/or mobile terms, privacy and security policies don't apply to the site or app you're about to visit. Please review its terms, privacy and security policies to see how they apply to you. J.P. Morgan Asset Management isn’t responsible for (and doesn't provide) any products, services or content at this third-party site or app, except for products and services that explicitly carry the J.P. Morgan Asset Management name.
CONTINUE Go Back
  1. Passing the baton to fiscal

  • LinkedIn Twitter Facebook

Passing the baton to fiscal

19/09/2019

Seamus Mac Gorain

The ECB’s decision last week to cut its policy rate and restart QE caused an unusual amount of disagreement, with a parade of central bank governors loudly voicing their opposition. Yet amid all the discord, the ECB governors were unanimous on one point: that fiscal policy should now take the baton from monetary policy as the main instrument to stimulate the economy. What is driving this increased focus on fiscal policy, and how likely is major fiscal stimulus?

Monetary policy side effects: Central banks have unleashed an extraordinary amount of monetary experimentation over the past decade, with over $11 trillion of QE and negative policy rates as low as -0.75%. They are now wondering how far they can push unconventional policies like negative rates, given the side effects such as impaired banking sector profitability. We don’t think we have yet reached the limits of negative rates. There is little evidence of cash hoarding to escape the negative return on large bank deposits. And for all the challenges to bank profitability, banks are still transmitting easy monetary policy to their customers via lower interest rates on consumer and corporate lending. All that said, we do think that pushing negative rates much lower than, say, -1% would probably require limits on cash holdings, quite a controversial step. Otherwise, the incentive to avoid negative rates by holding cash, yielding zero, would be too great.

Monetary policy effectiveness: The other main critique of unconventional monetary policy is that, while it may have been helpful in the depths of the crisis, it is at this stage only boosting asset prices, with little impact on growth or inflation. We do think that QE is still helpful, especially in easing funding costs in the Eurozone periphery. But we agree that fiscal policy would provide a more powerful boost to the economy. After all, monetary policy can only lower funding costs; it can’t force consumers, corporations and governments to spend. Fiscal policy directly increases spending in the economy.

An invitation from the bond market: Bond markets are inviting governments to spend. A case in point is the US, where the government deficit is rising with unemployment around its lowest in decades, precisely the opposite of the usual countercyclical approach to fiscal policy. Far from protesting at this, US Treasury bonds have flirted with all-time low yields over the past month. A different case is Italy, where bouts of political uncertainty have caused significant spikes in yields over the past few years. Even so, Italy’s debt has been steadily rising, while yields are also close to all-time lows.

Inflation expectations are low: For all their monetary inventiveness, central banks have failed to arrest the fall in inflation [in most countries] and inflation expectations [almost everywhere]. Quite apart from boosting growth, and – if well-designed – potential growth, easier fiscal policy could provide the impetus needed to reanchor inflation expectations closer to central bank targets. Some of the loudest calls for fiscal easing recently have come from advocates of money-financed fiscal expansion, based on Modern Monetary Theory [see the critique from my colleagues Ed Fitzpatrick and Kelsey Berro here – MMT: Short-term gain vs. Long-term pain]. But a more measured version of the same theme is simply that currently depressed inflation expectations provide scope for fiscal expansion.

Political constraints: In the near term, we see quite a few political constraints preventing governments from accepting the bond market’s invitation to spend. The US has a divided Congress heading into an election year. The Eurozone, and especially Germany, is constrained by constitutional borrowing limits, reflecting an ingrained aversion to government debt in many countries. We do expect some fiscal easing from Germany, but it is more likely to be a modest package, in line with the Federal government’s 0.5% of GDP wiggle room relative to the constitutional debt brake, than a fiscal bazooka. Japan is implementing some fiscal measures, but only as a counterpoint to a long-planned increase in sales tax. The UK is one developed economy where the fiscal narrative has clearly turned, and whichever government presents the next budget is going to turn the page on a decade of austerity. All told, that still leaves the onus on central banks to support the economy for now.

Watch elections, and Japan: In the medium term, we think the main policy response to the next recession will be fiscal stimulus, coupled with QE to absorb the resulting increased supply of government bonds. The trigger point for the shift could be economic weakness, or elections in which a platform of borrowing to spend at these very low yields proves a winning proposition. Japan’s economy and markets have long been a harbinger of what was to happen elsewhere. In recent years, the Bank of Japan has been hoovering up the Japanese government bond market, with limited success in pushing inflation higher. But importantly, instead of using this monetary support as an opportunity to spend more, the Japanese government has so far been reducing its deficit. In Japan and elsewhere, we will be watching closely to see when the baton is passed.

  • Central Banks
  • Market Views
  • Eurozone
  • Rates
  • Monetary Policy

RELATED ARTICLES

A Road to Recovery

In response to Europe’s biggest growth shock in a generation the EU council agreed on the outline of the “Recovery Fund” to help cushion the economic fallout from the pandemic.

Read more

Emerging markets and the negative yield conundrum for fixed income investors

Record low bond yields pose a major problem for fixed income investors. We explore why taking active FX risk can be a solution for investors.

Read more

The ECB's strategy review: Actions speak louder than words

With the ECB quickly running out of tools and inflation still some way from their current target, the market will be keen to hear what comes next.

Read more
JPMorgan Asset Management

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Financial Services Guide
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Investment Stewardship
  • Voting Policy
  • Unit Pricing Policy
  • Complaint Resolution
  • Sitemap
J.P. Morgan

  • J.P. Morgan
  • JPMorgan Chase
  • Chase

Please note:  Following recent amendments to the Corporations Act, where unitholders have provided us with your email address, we will now send notices of meetings, other meeting-related documents and annual financial reports electronically unless the unitholder elects to receive these in physical form and notify us of this election. Unitholders have the right to elect whether to receive some or all of such Communications in electronic or physical form, the right to elect not to receive annual financial reports at all and the right to elect to receive a single specified Communication on an ad hoc basis, in an electronic or physical form.


 

All investments contain risk and may lose value. This advertisement has been prepared and issued by JPMorgan Asset Management (Australia) Limited (ABN 55 143 832 080) (AFSL No. 376919) being the investment manager of the fund. It is for general information only, without taking into account your objectives, financial situation or needs and does not constitute personal financial advice. Before making any decision, it is important for investors to consider the appropriateness of the information and seek appropriate legal, tax, and other professional advice. For more detailed information relating to the risks of the Fund, the type of customer (target market) it has been designed for and any distribution conditions please refer to the relevant Product Disclosure Statement and Target Market Determination which have been issued by Perpetual Trust Services Limited, ABN 48 000 142 049, AFSL 236648, as the responsible entity of the fund available on https://am.jpmorgan.com/au.