Skip to main content
logo
Financial Professional Login
Welcome
Log in for exclusive access and a personalised experience
Log in Sign up
Benefits of creating a free account
  • Customise Guide to the Markets to create a version with your favourite slides
  • Utilise our adviser-only Digital Portfolio Insights tool
  • Unlock expert commentary from Michael Cembalest and access our annual Long-Term Capital Market Assumptions
Hello
  • My Collections
    View saved content and presentation slides
  • Portfolio Analysis
  • Funds
    Overview

    Fund Listing

    • Mutual Funds
    • ETFs
    • ETF Range
    • How to Invest

    Capabilities

    • Alternatives
    • Equities
    • Fixed Income
    • ETF Investing

    In Focus

    • Investing for Income
    • Investing for Fixed Income
    • Investing for Growth
    • Investing for Sustainability
    • Investing for Alternatives
  • Insights
    Overview

    Market Insights

    • Market Insights Overview
    • Guide to the Markets
    • Guide to Alternatives
    • Guide to Investing in Asia
    • Weekly Market Recap
    • On the Minds of Investors
    • Podcasts
    • U.S. Policy Pulse Hub
    • Solving for Fixed Income
    • Eye on the Market

    Portfolio Insights

    • Portfolio Insights Overview
    • Guide to ETFs
    • Global Asset Allocation Views
    • Global Equity Views
    • Global Fixed Income Views
    • Sustainable Investing
    • Alternatives Insights
    • Long-Term Capital Market Assumptions
  • Investment Ideas
    Overview
    • Latest ideas
    • Alternatives Outlook
    • Sustainable investing
  • Resources
    Overview
    • Multimedia
    • Insights App
    • Digital Portfolio Insights
    • Announcements
  • About Us
    Overview
    • Awards
    • Diversity, Opportunity and Inclusion
    • Spectrum: Our Investment Platform
    • Our Leadership Team
  • Contact Us
  • Role
  • Country
Hello
  • My Collections
    View saved content and presentation slides
  • Portfolio Analysis
  • Log out
Financial Professional Login
Welcome
Log in for exclusive access and a personalised experience
Log in Sign up
Benefits of creating a free account
  • Customise Guide to the Markets to create a version with your favourite slides
  • Utilise our adviser-only Digital Portfolio Insights tool
  • Unlock expert commentary from Michael Cembalest and access our annual Long-Term Capital Market Assumptions
Log out
Search
Menu
Search
You are about to leave the site Close
J.P. Morgan Asset Management’s website and/or mobile terms, privacy and security policies don't apply to the site or app you're about to visit. Please review its terms, privacy and security policies to see how they apply to you. J.P. Morgan Asset Management isn’t responsible for (and doesn't provide) any products, services or content at this third-party site or app, except for products and services that explicitly carry the J.P. Morgan Asset Management name.
CONTINUE Go Back
  1. Talking about ending QT is not the same as doing it

  • LinkedIn Twitter Facebook WhatsApp

Talking about ending QT is not the same as doing it

07/03/2019

Andrew Norelli

Given the market’s buoyancy over the past two months since the Powell Pivot, we could all be forgiven for thinking the Fed’s jawboning is just as good as actual policy action. There was a fair amount going on under the radar though which contributed to that potentially false sense of security. Back in January, I outlined a case for market strength through the end of February, based on a temporary reprieve from tight liquidity conditions (QT) which were otherwise stifling markets through the Three Phases cycles in 2018. I was focused at that time on the upcoming dynamics of the Treasury General Account, but there was another fortuitous dynamic at work too in the Fed’s securities roll-off that I missed, which I’ll briefly detail below. The upshot is that right when the Fed began to signal their plans to end QT “later this year,” quirks in the balance sheet dynamics actually resulted in periods of growth of bank reserves. This meant a sneaky and unintended pause in QT right when the Fed discussed a permanent end to it at some unknown future date. The market got a dose of what no-QT feels like, but now in March, the reality of $50 billion per month of liquidity withdrawal is likely to return.

In January, I suggested that because of a requirement in the 2018 legislation which suspended the debt ceiling, the Treasury would be required to spend down its “checking account” held at the Fed (the Treasury General Account or TGA) by a substantial amount by March 1st. They did that (Chart 1), and for reasons I laid out in the last post, this had a similar impact on the money supply as Quantitative Easing.


Auspiciously, at about the same time as the Treasury was a net spender of money into the economy, there was a bit of a dead spot in the roll-off of securities held on the Fed’s balance sheet, so that in aggregate, the QT amounts did not reach the desired $50bn per month pace. For the six weeks ending February 13, 2019, only about $31bn worth of securities matured, which is less than half the speed of QT allowed by size of the roll-off caps. After February 13th, the TGA effect intensified.

The combination of these two effects has generally held the quantity of bank reserves in the system so far in 2019 roughly flat, whereas the pace of reserve drain in 2018 proceeded briskly without interruption (Chart 2).


This is about to change. We expect the Treasury to rebuild the TGA as they undertake the first phase of “Extraordinary Measures,” in which they free up some space in the debt ceiling through accounting maneuvers with the Treasury holdings of various Federal employee pension funds. The timing of that is uncertain, but at a minimum the TGA should stop shrinking here for a time. Additionally, the roll-off calendar for securities held on the Fed’s balance sheet is less friendly. In essence, the dead spot is over and QT is now proceeding on-pace for $50bn per month.

Reluctantly, I still feel like this sets the market up for one last period of stress which ultimately forces the Fed out of QT. In other words, I think QT ends on the market’s terms, not the Fed’s. I say that because I still think that negative balance sheet flow – a shrinking monetary base – is a negative thrust on asset prices even if the Fed has already clearly signaled their intention to end it “later this year.”

Simultaneously, there is significant optimism in the market right now for the growth effects of Chinese stimulus – particularly the January spike in Total Social Financing which injected a record 5% of GDP worth of new loans in just one month. That is a green shoot for sure, but prior episodes of Chinese stimulus through an acceleration of indebtedness (a positive credit “impulse”) had a demonstrably lagged effect on global growth, industrial production, EMFX, and the Chinese domestic economy. Historically, those lags were about 6 to 9 months. So, that takes us to July for the effects to show up in the data. Meanwhile, the near term trajectory of data in Europe, China, and US may or may not improve, but any improvement probably won’t be because of Chinese credit creation. The timing of this lagged effect of Chinese stimulus also leaves us with a potential void of helpful data over the near term while the markets await confirmation of the size and effects of Chinese stimulus.

Bottom line, my expectations for the year as a whole have not changed since January, but the markets and the calendar have moved on to the next part of the pathway where near-term caution is once again warranted.

  • Central Banks
  • Market Views
  • Monetary Policy
  • Economic Outlook

RELATED ARTICLES

Watch the lag: thoughts on core CPI (part 2 – an update)

We analyze which economic indicators the Fed should pay attention to and which ones are false alarms.

Read more

The forest and the trees

When constantly watching financial markets and following the 24-7 news flow, it can be easy to get caught up in the trees and miss the forest.

Read more

Getting the market back on its feet

Market functionality needs to be restored no matter how anyone feels about the methods it may take to get there. If the current market conditions persist, the consequences may be severe.

Read more
JPMorgan Asset Management

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Financial Services Guide
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Investment Stewardship
  • Voting Policy
  • Unit Pricing Policy
  • Complaint Resolution
  • Sitemap
J.P. Morgan

  • J.P. Morgan
  • JPMorgan Chase
  • Chase

Please note:  Following recent amendments to the Corporations Act, where unitholders have provided us with your email address, we will now send notices of meetings, other meeting-related documents and annual financial reports electronically unless the unitholder elects to receive these in physical form and notify us of this election. Unitholders have the right to elect whether to receive some or all of such Communications in electronic or physical form, the right to elect not to receive annual financial reports at all and the right to elect to receive a single specified Communication on an ad hoc basis, in an electronic or physical form.


 

All investments contain risk and may lose value. This advertisement has been prepared and issued by JPMorgan Asset Management (Australia) Limited (ABN 55 143 832 080) (AFSL No. 376919) being the investment manager of the fund. It is for general information only, without taking into account your objectives, financial situation or needs and does not constitute personal financial advice. Before making any decision, it is important for investors to consider the appropriateness of the information and seek appropriate legal, tax, and other professional advice. For more detailed information relating to the risks of the Fund, the type of customer (target market) it has been designed for and any distribution conditions please refer to the relevant Product Disclosure Statement and Target Market Determination which have been issued by Perpetual Trust Services Limited, ABN 48 000 142 049, AFSL 236648, as the responsible entity of the fund available on https://am.jpmorgan.com/au.