European Union (EU) governments and business leaders believe that one of the best ways to achieve their sustainability goals is to encourage capital to flow towards efforts that promote and enable a more sustainable economy. Many investors also support this objective, but often lack enough information to assess and compare sustainable investment options on the basis of how they are aligned to their investment goals.
The EU Action Plan on Sustainable Finance, which features a series of interlinking regulations designed to encourage sustainable investing, represents a major step towards redirecting capital to the sustainable economy. A key part of the plan is the EU Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (EU SFDR), which came into effect on 10 March 2021. Further regulations have followed, including the EU Taxonomy Regulation1, effective from January 2022, which establishes specific environmental criteria related to economic activities for investment purposes, and which forms part of the enhanced disclosure obligations required by the EU SFDR2. An extended environmental transitioning taxonomy and a social taxonomy are expected to follow.
In this Q&A, we look specifically at the EU SFDR, seeking to explain the importance of this wide-reaching regulation and to show the expected impact to asset managers, advisers and investors alike.
The EU SFDR is a regulation that is designed to make it easier for investors to distinguish and compare between the many sustainable investment strategies that are now available within the European Union. The EU SFDR aims to help investors by providing more transparency on the degree to which financial products consider environmental and/or social characteristics, invest in sustainable investments or have sustainable objectives. This information is now being presented in a more standardised way.
The EU SFDR requires specific firm-level disclosures from asset managers and investment advisers regarding how they address two key considerations: Sustainability Risks and Principal Adverse Impacts. With regards to asset managers, the EU SFDR also mandates transparency of remuneration policies in relation to the integration of sustainability risks. In addition, the EU SFDR aims to help investors to choose between products by mandating increasing levels of disclosures, depending on the degree to which sustainability is a consideration.
Three different product categorisations result from EU SFDR:
- "Article 6" products either integrate financially material environmental, social and governance (ESG) risk considerations into the investment decision-making process, or explain why sustainability risk is not relevant, but do not meet the additional criteria of Article 8 or Article 9 products3.
- “Article 8” products promote social and/or environmental characteristics, and may invest in sustainable investments, but do not have sustainable investing as a core objective.
- “Article 9” products have a sustainable investment objective.
It is important to note that these product categories are not labels, although many investment firms have treated them as such (see below, “What are the additional upcoming developments that investors should be aware of?” for more information on this issue).
The EU SFDR also introduces asset level considerations, definitions and conditionality, dividing investments into those that (i) have environmental and/or social characteristics, (ii) can be considered “sustainable”, and (iii) “other” (investments that do not meet either of the two preceding criteria).4
The disclosures, which went into effect on 10 March 2021 – and which apply to several financial products, including UCITS, AIFs and segregated mandates – were rolled out in two phases:
- Core disclosures (Level 1) effective March 2021, which apply at an entity level to Sustainability Risks and Principal Adverse Impacts, and at a product level to Article 6, 8 and 9 products.
- Enhanced disclosures (Level 2) effective January 20235, which apply at an entity level to Principal Adverse Impacts, and at a product level to only Article 8 and 9 products.
It is important to note that regulators continue to issue new guidance and statements related to these disclosures and how they should be interpreted, and industry understanding of these requirements continues to evolve6.
The EU SFDR is designed to re-orient capital towards sustainable growth and help clients make better sustainable investing choices.
The primary goals are to provide greater transparency on environmental and social characteristics, and sustainability within the financial markets, and to create common standards for reporting and disclosing information related to these considerations.
Increasing transparency and introducing standards supports two important additional considerations. First, it makes it harder for asset managers to “greenwash” their products – in other words, they cannot simply brand a product with an ESG or sustainable label, without being transparent with regards to how this is achieved.
Second, it provides investors with a significantly improved ability to compare investment options in terms of the degree to which ESG factors are a consideration within the investment decision-making process, which helps them make informed decisions that align with their investing goals.
The scope of the EU SFDR is relatively broad, applying to all financial market participants and financial advisers based in the EU, as well as investment managers or advisers based outside of the EU, who market (or intend to market) their products to clients in the EU under Article 42 of the Alternative Investment Fund Managers Directive (EU AIFMD).
In terms of products, the disclosures regime applies to UCITS, AIFs, separately-managed portfolios and sub-advisory mandates, as well as to financial advice (provided within the EU or by an EU investment firm).
While the UK is out of the scope of the EU SFDR, in October 2022 the UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) issued a consultation paper with regards to Sustainability Disclosure Requirements and investment labels (UK SDR)7, which builds on a prior Discussion Paper8 that in part parallels the EU SFDR. This initiative follows the FCA’s alignment to the Financial Stability Board (FSB) Task Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosures (TCFD)9. Final rules related to the UK SDR are expected the third quarter of 2023.
To achieve the EU SFDR’s goal of improving sustainable finance by increasing transparency and creating standards, asset managers and advisers must disclose the manner in which they consider two key factors: Sustainability Risks and Principal Adverse Impacts. Subject to specific thresholds, asset managers are required to disclose their policies at both the firm and product level, while advisers are required to explain how they consider these factors in their advice.
The EU SFDR outlines specific definitions for Sustainability Risks and Principal Adverse Impacts:
- Sustainability Risks refer to environmental, social or governance events, or conditions, such as climate change, that could cause an actual or a potential material negative impact on the value of an investment.
- Principal Adverse Impacts are any negative effects that investment decisions or advice could have on sustainability factors. Examples could include investing in a company with business operations that significantly contribute to carbon dioxide emissions, or that has poor water, waste or land management practices.
Asset managers and advisers need to provide specific information on Sustainability Risks and Principal Adverse Impacts
Larger firms (having more than 500 employees) are required to disclose how they consider Principal Adverse Impacts from 30 June 2021, with reporting of Principal Adverse Impacts estimated to commence mid-2023 (representing Principal Adverse Impacts data throughout 2022).
Effective 1 January 2023, asset managers are now required to break out how they consider Principal Adverse Impacts into more specific and quantifiable detail, with reference to indicators related to climate and the environment, and indicators related to social and employee issues, respect for human rights, and anti-corruption and anti-bribery matters. Out of the current 64 environmental and social indicators, which can be grouped into broader categories, such as greenhouse gas emissions, biodiversity or water, 18 are core, and for the other 46, investment managers have some flexibility with regards to providing detail on the impacts.
Interest in Principal Adverse Impacts has increased following the inclusion of client sustainability preferences within EU MiFID II, which came into effect on 2 August 202210. One of the ways that clients may now elect to express their sustainability preferences is through the consideration of Principal Averse Impacts on sustainability factors in investments. As a result, some investment managers and advisers disclose how Principal Adverse Impacts are considered in an investment.
Example of considering Principle Adverse Impacts in an investment
For asset managers, the incorporation of Sustainability Risks and Principal Adverse Impacts takes place at several points in the investment process.
Checklist for asset managers incorporating Sustainability Risks and Principal Adverse Impacts into the investment process
Along with the other considerations referenced above, it is worth recognising that regulators continue to review the Principal Adverse Impacts and financial product disclosure requirements in the EU SFDR Delegated Regulation. In November 2022 the European Commission invited the European Supervisory Authorities to: (1) streamline and develop further the regulatory framework; (2) consider extending the lists of universal indicators for Principal Adverse Impacts, as well as other indicators; and (3) refine the content of all the indicators for adverse impacts and their respective definitions, applicable methodologies, metrics and presentation.11 As a result, new PAIs have been put forward as part of a wider review and consultation paper related to EU SFDR12.
As defined in question 1 (“What is the EU SFDR?”), the EU SFDR currently specifies three distinct levels of disclosure for investment products with regards to sustainable investing and ESG considerations.
Article 6 financial products must disclose the manner in which sustainability risks are integrated into their investment decisions as well as an assessment of the likely impacts of sustainability risks on the returns of the financial products.
Article 8 and Article 9 financial products feature details on a variety of sustainability and ESG topics. The table below highlights a sample of the topics, though it is not a complete list.
Sample of topics featured in the disclosures for both Article 8 and Article 9 products
Additional disclosures: EU Taxonomy
The EU Taxonomy Regulation (EU TR), which introduces standard environmental criteria within the EU, came into effect on 1 January 2022. From 1 January 2023, elements of the EU TR were integrated into the disclosure obligations set out by the EU SFDR13. This development affected financial products that were classified as either Article 8 or Article 9. The specific EU TR elements to be disclosed under the EU SFDR are outlined below:
Article 8 products need to state if they have any investments in sustainable investments and, if so, need to disclose whether these investments are in activities aligned with the EU TR.
Article 9 products, which by definition have sustainable investment as an objective, have to disclose whether their sustainable investments are in activities aligned with the EU TR.
You can find more information on the EU TR, and how it interacts with the EU SFDR, here.
There remain additional items for investors to watch:
- Enhancements to EU SFDR: As stated above, the EU is currently exploring enhancing the existing EU SFDR and issued a consultation paper to that effect in April 2023 (“version 1.5”)14. In addition, it is expected there will be other changes over and above those proposed by this consultation paper, introducing “version 2" of the regulation15.
- ESG-related EU fund naming rules: A consultation paper on guidelines for fund names using ESG or sustainability-related terms was issued by ESMA in November 2022, addressing how funds may be named16. A final report on this topic is expected prior to the end of 2023 / start of 2024.
- UK disclosures and labels: As noted earlier, in October 2022 the UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) issued a consultation paper with regards to Sustainability Disclosure Requirements and investment labels (UK SDR)17, creating a parallel disclosure framework that goes beyond the EU SFDR by (among other items) introducing investment labels.
- Evolution of parallel regulations: Additional developments driven by both the European Platform on Sustainable Finance and the European Commission will need to be reviewed, particularly their focus on a potential social taxonomy18, an extended environmental transitioning taxonomy19 and enhancements to minimum safeguard requirements20. In June 2023 ESMA issued a “Call for evidence on the integration of sustainability preferences in the suitability assessment and product governance arrangements” which may result in additional changes to that regime21.
- Parallel initiatives: Third-party ESG-related industry standards will need to be reviewed as they get updated to align with the EU SFDR and the EU Taxonomy Regulation.
- Additional ex-EU developments: Parallel regulatory labelling requirements and/or related regulatory disclosure requirements from regulators in other regions, such as the Hong Kong Securities and Futures Commission, and the Security and Exchange Commission amendments to the fund “names rule”22, may interact with the EU SFDR and have an aggregated impact on products and disclosures.
Looking ahead
The EU SFDR represents a positive step in the growth and development of sustainable and ESG investing within the EU. As investor interest in sustainable and ESG investing continues to grow, the regulation offers investors clear comparisons and advice on ESG and sustainable investments, enabling asset managers and advisers to help capital flow towards investment products that support a sustainable economy.
J.P. Morgan Asset Management is proud to help clients achieve their ESG and sustainable investing goals. If you have questions about the EU SFDR or sustainable investing, please contact your local J.P. Morgan Asset Management representative.
1 The Taxonomy Regulation was published in the Official Journal of the European Union on 22 June 2020 and entered into force on 12 July 2020. The regulation sets out four overarching conditions that an economic activity has to meet in order to qualify as environmentally sustainable
2 On 25 November 2021, the European Commission sent a letter to the European Parliament and the Council of the European Union announcing a delay to the date of application of regulatory technical standards (RTS) under EU SFDR. The Commission deferred implementation of the SFDR RTS to 1 January 2023: https://www.esma.europa.eu/sites/default/files/library/com_letter_to_ep_and_council_sfdr_rts-j.berrigan.pdf
3 J.P. Morgan Asset Management defines ESG integration as the systematic inclusion of financially material ESG factors (alongside other relevant factors) in investment analysis and investment decisions. In actively managed assets deemed by J.P. Morgan Asset Management to be ESG integrated under our governance process, we systematically assess financially material ESG factors including sustainability risks in our investment decisions with the goals of managing risk and improving long-term returns.
4 The EU SFDR asset level definition of a “sustainable investment” is related, but separate to, the EU TR standard of a “sustainable investment”. See our article for more information
5 https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:32022R1288&from=EN
6 In June 2022 the European Supervisory Authorities provided clarifications on their draft RTS under SFDR, and in September 2022 submitted additional SFDR queries requiring the interpretation of Union law to the European Commission. In November ESMA issued new guidance on the EU SFDR providing answers to some key questions
7 https://www.fca.org.uk/publication/consultation/cp22-20.pdf
8 https://www.fca.org.uk/publication/discussion/dp21-4.pdf
9 https://www.fca.org.uk/publication/policy/ps21-24.pdf
10 https://jpmam.ft.com/why-2022-is-a-key-year-for-sustainability-related-disclosures
11 https://www.esma.europa.eu/document/mandate-esas-pai-product
12 https://www.esma.europa.eu/sites/default/files/2023-04/JC_2023_09_Joint_consultation_paper_on_review_of_SFDR_Delegated_Regulation.pdf
13 https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:32022R1288&from=EN
14 https://www.esma.europa.eu/sites/default/files/2023-04/JC_2023_09_Joint_consultation_paper_on_review_of_SFDR_Delegated_Regulation.pdf
15 https://finance.ec.europa.eu/sustainable-finance/disclosures/sustainability-related-disclosure-financial-services-sector_en
16 https://www.esma.europa.eu/sites/default/files/library/esma34-472-373_guidelines_on_funds_names.pdf
17 https://www.fca.org.uk/publication/consultation/cp22-20.pdf
18 https://ec.europa.eu/info/sites/default/files/business_economy_euro/banking_and_finance/documents/280222-sustainable-finance-platform-finance-report-social-taxonomy.pdf
19 https://ec.europa.eu/info/sites/default/files/business_economy_euro/banking_and_finance/documents/220329-sustainable-finance-platform-finance-report-environmental-transition-taxonomy_en.pdf
20 https://ec.europa.eu/info/sites/default/files/business_economy_euro/banking_and_finance/documents/draft-report-minimum-safeguards-july2022_en.pdf
21 https://www.esma.europa.eu/sites/default/files/2023-06/ESMA35-43-3599_Call_for_evidence_on_MiFID_II_suitability_and_sustainability.pdf
22 https://www.sec.gov/files/ic-34593-fact-sheet.pdf
09uw221006090317