Is the flattening yield curve a sign of trouble ahead?Contributors Karen Ward, Jai Malhi
The yield curve may have lost its predictive power if it no longer provides a signal about the stance of policy.
Historically, an inverted yield curve has been a useful indicator of recessions. However, quantitative easing may have distorted that signal. Therefore, we would not rely solely on the yield curve but also look at other indicators to track economic momentum.
In recent days the US yield curve has flirted with inversion. As shown in Exhibit 1 from our Guide to the Markets, the two-year Treasury yield is now broadly at the level of the 10-year yield. An inverted yield curve has been a useful indicator of recessions in the past, so this inversion is generating considerable concern among investors.
EXHIBIT 1: THE US YIELD CURVE
Source: (All charts) Bloomberg, Federal Reserve, Thomson Reuters Datastream, J.P. Morgan Asset Management. Periods of "recession" are defined using US National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) business cycle dates. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of current and future results. Guide to the Markets - UK. Data as of 14 August 2019.
Why has the yield curve proved such a good indicator of downturns? Largely, the yield curve has been a useful predictor of the health of the economy because it contains information about whether the central bank has its foot on the accelerator or the brake. Long-term interest rates should reflect “neutral” policy: i.e. interest rates that do not serve to either boost or restrict activity. A steep curve suggests short-term interest rates are below neutral (and stimulative), while an inverted curve suggests short-term interest rates are above neutral (and thus restrictive).
The time between policy becoming relatively tight and the economy actually slowing has varied greatly in the past, but there is often a lengthy lag. On average, the curve has inverted 17 months ahead of the equity market peak and 22 months ahead of the economic peak. In the mid 1990s, the curve was broadly flat for a period of about five years. Over that period both the economy and the stock market boomed, fuelled by optimism about the promise of new technologies.
It is possible that quantitative easing (QE) has reduced the signalling capacity of the yield curve. QE was designed to purposefully depress long-term bond yields below an economically "neutral" rate. One way of gauging the impact of global QE is to consider term premia—the excess yield investors require to lock up money in a long-term bond. With the slowdown in global growth prompted by trade concerns central banks have committed to further monetary easing. This is having an enormous impact on long-term interest rates and pushing the US term premium to a new low (Exhibit 2).
EXHIBIT 2: US 10-YEAR TREASURY TERM PREMIUM
Source: Bloomberg, J.P. Morgan Asset Management. Adrian Crump & Moench measure of the US 10-year treasury term premium. Data as of 13 August 2019.
For this reason the yield curve may have lost its predictive power if it no longer provides a signal about the stance of policy today relative to neutral. The curve could be flat or even inverted while interest rates still remain stimulative to the real economy and thus are not serving to depress activity.
There could be a causal link between the yield curve and an economic slowdown if a flat or inverted curve depresses activity by reducing the willingness of commercial banks to lend. Net interest margins will be reduced when the curve inverts given that banks typically borrow at short-rates and lend at long-rates.
However, a flattening yield curve has not historically translated into less credit growth, quite the opposite in fact (Exhibit 3). The propensity of the banks to continue lending as the yield curve flattens likely reflects the fact that household and corporate optimism—and therefore the appetite to borrow— tends to build through the cycle. At the same time, impairments tend to be relatively low, which encourages banks to lend.
EXHIBIT 3: US YIELD CURVE AND COMMERCIAL BANK CREDIT GROWTH
%, 10-year Treasury yield minus 2-year Treasury yield (LHS); % change year on year (RHS)
Source: Federal Reserve, Thomson Reuters Datastream, J.P. Morgan Asset Management. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of current and future results. Data as of 14 August 2019.
In summary, we would not rely solely on the predictive power of the yield curve in this cycle. Instead we will focus our efforts on tracking business and consumer sentiment, and the labour market (Exhibit 4), which have all historically provided robust leading indicators of a downturn—and which also provide no obvious reasons to question the signals they are giving this time around. These indicators do show that the US is slowing. At present they do not suggest the US is headed towards a recession but we are concerned about recent developments in the trade war between the US and China and what that will do to corporate sentiment. Indicators of employment intentions are key to understanding whether this turns from a manufacturing led moderate slowdown to a broader economic problem. As a result, we believe a more modest approach to risk is appropriate at this stage, with equity portfolios that have more defensive properties (see our On the Minds of Investors1 article.)
EXHIBIT 4: US EQUITY MACRO CORRELATIONS
Source: (Left) Conference Board, Standard & Poor’s, Thomson Reuters Datastream, J.P. Morgan Asset Management. (Right) BLS, Standard & Poor’s, Thomson Reuters Datastream, J.P. Morgan Asset Management. Periods of "recession" are defined using US National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) business cycle dates. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of current and future results. Guide to the Markets - UK. Data as of 14 August 2019.
1 How should we prepare portfolios for the next downturn?, Michael Bell, J.P. Morgan Asset Management, October 2018.
Today’s top questions
How could trade tensions affect global markets?
Why invest in alternative assets?
Finding income in a low yield environment
Are emerging market assets worth the volatility?
Is the flattening yield curve a sign of trouble ahead?
Europe at a crossroads: Recession or turnaround?
Are we on the brink of a global trade war?
Opportunities in emerging markets
How is the EM capital market landscape changing?
This document is a general communication being provided for informational purposes only. It is educational in nature and not designed to be taken as advice or a recommendation for any specific investment product, strategy, plan feature or other purpose in any jurisdiction, nor is it a commitment from J.P. Morgan Asset Management or any of its subsidiaries to participate in any of the transactions mentioned herein. Any examples used are generic, hypothetical and for illustration purposes only. This material does not contain sufficient information to support an investment decision and it should not be relied upon by you in evaluating the merits of investing in any securities or products. In addition, users should make an independent assessment of the legal, regulatory, tax, credit, and accounting implications and determine, together with their own professional advisers, if any investment mentioned herein is believed to be suitable to their personal goals. Investors should ensure that they obtain all available relevant information before making any investment. Any forecasts, figures, opinions or investment techniques and strategies set out are for information purposes only, based on certain assumptions and current market conditions and are subject to change without prior notice. All information presented herein is considered to be accurate at the time of production, but no warranty of accuracy is given and no liability in respect of any error or omission is accepted. It should be noted that investment involves risks, the value of investments and the income from them may fluctuate in accordance with market conditions and taxation agreements and investors may not get back the full amount invested. Both past performance and yields is not a reliable indicator of current and future results.
J.P. Morgan Asset Management is the brand for the asset management business of JPMorgan Chase & Co. and its affiliates worldwide. This communication is issued in the United Kingdom by JPMorgan Asset Management (UK) Limited, which is authorized and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority, Registered in England No. 01161446. Registered address: 25 Bank Street, Canary Wharf, London E14 5JP.